NextUpcoming meetingsAll dates →
Stop the CMP Line, Alliance for Responsible Infrastructure
Independent ReviewThe CaseImpactsHealth & SafetyTake ActionResourcesDonate
Independent ReviewThe CaseImpactsHealth & SafetyTake ActionResources

Why this project needs an independent review.

CMP identifies the need, proposes the solution and earns a return on what it builds. A decision this large should not rest on that company’s word.

$547MCMP’s Phase 1 estimate
9.57%return on equity in CMP’s own cost model for this project
$69Mcharged to customers in 2031 alone, by CMP’s model
45–70years these assets are paid off and earn a return

ODR-001-010 Att. 1, DOER-001-004: case page, Data Requests tab ↗

CMP’s incentiveHow CMP weighs alternativesWho checks the needOn the recordWhat we’re asking for

CMP’s incentive

The more CMP builds, the more it earns.

“That’s how the utility makes money … by making their rate of return on the capital investments that they have built.”

Public Advocate Heather Sanborn, Oct. 21, 2026. City meeting ↗

What CMP earns a return on

  • New poles and wires
  • New and expanded substations
  • A bigger project, and a bigger base to earn on

What earns CMP nothing

  • Lower demand and efficiency
  • Solar, batteries and local generation owned by others

The return is only fair if the need is real. The Commission’s own independent management audit of CMP, reported in 2021, found an “overemphasis on closing earnings gaps.”

Liberty Consulting Group, 2021. Full audit ↗ · Bangor Daily News ↗

How CMP weighs alternatives

The same incentive shapes the route.

CMP’s parent company’s written procedure for choosing a project starts with the land the company already owns and favors whatever carries less “cost and risk to the project” itself. Nothing in it measures the net economic impact on the community. How CMP picks a route →

Iberdrola USA procedure (2015), filed by CMP as EXM-004-001 Att. 1, pp. 6, 15: case page, Data Requests tab ↗

Who checks the need

The state’s non-wires reviewer doesn’t check CMP’s forecast.

What CMP told FalmouthThe state’s non-wires coordinator “validates the identified system needs.” Item 238, p. 9 ↗
What the Public Advocate told the CommissionThe coordinator “does not undertake an independent load forecast to validate the projections,” and “cannot propose solutions with a lower forecasted capability.” Item 141, p. 5 ↗

Load means the total electricity an area uses, which is a different question from whether today’s equipment holds up. CMP built its study on ISO New England’s 2024 forecast of load. The 2025 forecast cut 115 MW from the 2030 summer peak, and the 2026 forecast is lower still. Item 141 ↗

On the record

They are all questioning CMP’s need.

Maine Public Advocate

CMP’s practices “raise concerns that the Portland area forecast of load is overestimated, potentially leading to unneeded capital investment.”

Its witness asked the Commission to “direct an independent review” and “defer approval of forecast-driven portions” of the project.

Item 141 ↗ · Item 210 ↗

City of Portland

Its primary concerns begin with “whether the need for the Project has been adequately demonstrated.”

“Alternate routes that avoid impacts on residences and conservation areas were not adequately studied.”

Item 209 ↗

Town of Falmouth

The request to test CMP’s need “casts reasonable doubt on the underlying assumptions” in its load growth estimates.

Falmouth’s schools ask the Commission to “fully examine the project’s underlying need and scale.”

Item 143 ↗ · Town of Falmouth testimony, Item 197 ↗, Exhibit E

Conservation Law Foundation

“Properly evaluating CMP’s proposed transmission project first requires resolving this doubt about the estimated load growth.”

Item 142 ↗

Town of Cumberland

The Town Council resolved on Nov. 9 to oppose the project as submitted.

It urged the Commission to “further examine the need and scale of the proposed improvements, consider practical alternative solutions and routes, including non-wires alternatives.” The Council directed the Town to file the resolution in the case.

Council agenda and resolution, Nov. 9 ↗

What we’re asking for

Check the need. Then design to it.

1An independent review of CMP’s forecast and the need it claims.
2A solution sized to the real need, “rather than beginning with the previously proposed Phase 1 solution.”
3A real evaluation of alternatives that do less harm to neighbors.

Quotation: Public Advocate’s witness, Item 210 ↗.

Ask the Commission for an independent review.

Your public comment goes straight into the case record.

File a public comment ↗All ways to help

Stand with your neighbors.

Alliance for Responsible Infrastructure · contact@ariforme.org · Docket No. 2025-00276
Nov9
CMP open house, Westbrook6–8pm, 426 Bridge St.
Nov9
Cumberland Town Council7pm, public comment
Nov10
ARI session + CMP open house, Portland4pm and 6pm, Presumpscot Elementary
Nov12
CMP open house, Cumberland6pm, Town Hall
Nov16
Portland City Council5pm, City Hall, public comment
Nov18
Portland Sustainability and TransportationTime on the posted agenda
Nov19
Yarmouth Town Council7pm
Dec10
Technical conference, Hallowell9am, 26 Katherine Dr, or streamed
0
Skip to Content
ARI
STOP the CMP Line
ARI's position of safety issues
ARI
STOP the CMP Line
ARI's position of safety issues
STOP the CMP Line
ARI's position of safety issues