The case: CMP’s proposal and alternative solutions.
We all want reliable power. CMP has to show this project is the right way to get it.
What CMP proposes
CMP’s $547 million first phase.
- A new 115 kV line through Cumberland, Falmouth and Portland, on steel poles up to about 110 feet tall.
- Rebuilt lines in Westbrook.
- Substation work: expanding Raven Farm and East Deering, a new Bayside substation, and removing Elm Street in Yarmouth.
- About $547 million, CMP’s estimate, with a stated range of −25% to +50%. A Phase 2 filing would follow.
CMP’s first phase is focused on Portland, and its case leans on a prediction of how much total electricity the area will use. That prediction comes from a regional forecast since revised down, and the Public Advocate has raised concerns that it’s overestimated. Towns north of Portland would get little to no benefit while bearing the harm.

See it on the map
Where CMP would build.
The existing corridor, where the new and rebuilt lines would run inside it, and how wide the clearing would be. Zoom in to find your street, and click any line for details.
Illustrative. Line positions are drawn from CMP’s cross-sections and public line data; they are not a survey and not a prediction for any one property. The Westbrook right-of-way width is assumed at 100 ft because CMP’s petition does not give one. The Portland rail-corridor alignment is approximated from CMP’s public images. Sources: CMP petition, pp. 29–30 and 37 ↗; CMP data responses AP01-001-018, EXM-004-002, ODR-001, ACAUS-001-001, AP01-001-013, MAS-001-008 (Data Requests tab ↗). Also see CMP’s project map ↗.
What the real need is
Reliability.
Reliability and load aren’t the same thing. Reliability, as most people mean it, is equipment that works and doesn’t fail. Load is the total electricity an area uses, and a forecast of more load is what calls for a bigger system. CMP folds the two together: its petition says the needs are “driven by forecasted load growth in the area and asset condition.” If the forecast is too high, part of that need goes away.
The needs CMP now points to are reliability problems: equipment that wore out and failed.
One worn-out part at the Elm Street substation knocked out power to 28,000 customers on Oct. 9. An 80-year-old line failed in 2023. Fix them. That’s upkeep, and it doesn’t take a new 115 kV line through people’s backyards. CMP’s own plan prices rebuilding the old lines and building the new 115 kV line as separate jobs.
CMP makes more money the more it builds.
It earns a return on every dollar it spends on projects like this one. Bigger project, bigger payday. That’s why someone independent has to check the need first.
CMP at Portland’s Sustainability and Transportation Committee, Oct. 21, 2026 ↗ (outages) · CMP petition, p. 1 ↗ (need) · CMP petition, Table 1, Cost Summary ↗ (separate line items) · ODR-001-010 Att. 1: case page, Data Requests tab ↗
The alternatives
CMP says it looked at alternatives. Its answers keep changing.
What the record shows: CMP has given at least four different bases for the cost of undergrounding. Its comparisons count construction only, not the net economic impact of each option.
Below: CMP’s own answers, and when it gave them. Text in quotation marks is CMP’s wording; the rest summarizes CMP’s own figures.
What CMP isn’t saying: its parent company’s procedure favors whatever carries less “cost and risk to the project” itself. The net economic impact on the community is never measured. Why an independent review matters →
The City of Portland, in its testimony: CMP’s petition “does not adequately explain why the Project could not continue to follow the railroad corridor.”
Petition, p. 48 ↗ · Item 174 ↗ · City of Portland meeting, Oct. 21 ↗ · Item 238, pp. 7–8 ↗ · Item 209 ↗ · MAS-001-009; Iberdrola USA procedure (2015), filed by CMP as EXM-004-001 Att. 1, pp. 6, 8–16: case page, Data Requests tab ↗
How CMP picks a route
CMP’s siting procedure starts with the land it already has.
Starts here
Real Estate’s “records that determine what IUSA owns for property.” IUSA is Iberdrola USA, CMP’s parent company at the time.
Protects
The project, not the neighbors. It favors whatever carries less “cost and risk to the project.” The “real estate costs” it works to minimize are what CMP pays for land rights. Neighbors’ property values are not a factor.
Leaves out
The criteria include parcels, buildings and permits. Nothing measures the net economic impact on the community.
Less destructive options deserve a real look:
Why an independent review matters →
Iberdrola USA, Project Options Analysis, filed by CMP as EXM-004-001 Att. 1, pp. 6, 8–16: case page, Data Requests tab ↗
Non-wires alternatives
The alternatives review starts from CMP’s own need.
Maine law requires a look at batteries, local generation and demand management. But the reviewer tests them against the need CMP identified, not whether that need is right.
“They take the needs the company identified at face value.”
Public Advocate Heather Sanborn, on the non-wires review, Oct. 21, 2026. Her office’s expert says that review rests on inputs “that have since changed.”
It has worked elsewhere, and in Maine.
A $1B+ substation deferred
Con Edison paired efficiency, demand response and batteries with smaller fixes, and earned a return on the program.
A third undersea cable deferred
National Grid installed a 6 MW battery and an on-island generator.
A 13-mile line avoided
Eversource built a 25 MW battery instead of a new line through the Cape Cod National Seashore.
110 MW from customer batteries
Green Mountain Power calls on leased home batteries at peak.
An $18M rebuild avoided
Local solar, batteries and efficiency “met reliability needs in the pilot area for less.”
237 MW of batteries
All owned by independent producers. None by CMP, which earns no return on them.
35-A M.R.S. § 3132(2-D) ↗ · Item 141, p. 5 ↗ · Item 210 ↗ · City meeting ↗ · NY PSC Case 14-E-0302; Energy-Storage.news; Utility Dive, Apr. 8, 2019; Electrek, July 28, 2026; Boothbay pilot Recommended Decision (2016); EIA.
Why we’re opposing it as proposed
Eight things CMP says, and what the record shows.
Each line below is a claim CMP makes for this project. Click or tap the + to see what the record shows.
“This project is urgently needed to keep the lights on in Greater Portland.”
“There's no real alternative to this version of the project.”
CMP’s case against the alternatives keeps changing. Its petition said an I-295 route would cost “more than six times” the proposed route (petition, p. 48), and CMP repeated that to Falmouth on Oct. 13 (Item 174). Seventeen days later it told Falmouth about 3.3 times (Item 238, p. 7). In September CMP said it dropped the rail corridor because MaineDOT said the corridor was not acceptable (data response MAS-001-009). Now it says the route was “not advanced primarily because of its substantially higher cost,” and that it is still “coordinating with MaineDOT to confirm the information used in its evaluation remains current.” It also puts the same price on its original design and its redesign, though the original needed about $10 million more in right-of-way (Item 238, p. 8). A decision this large should rest on numbers that hold still. The Commission should require an independent look at the alternatives. What CMP isn’t saying: its parent company’s written procedure for choosing a project starts with the land the company already owns and favors whatever carries less “cost and risk to the project” itself (Iberdrola USA, filed by CMP as EXM-004-001 Att. 1, pp. 6, 15). Nothing in it measures the net economic impact on the community. Why an independent review matters →
“This project is for the public good.”
“This project serves 200,000 customers in the Greater Portland area.”
“This won't have a big impact on landowners.”
“CMP informed landowners and impacted parties before filing.”
“Clearing the right-of-way just means trimming a few trees.”
“This is the best solution to meet Portland's future energy needs.”
Where the case stands
The Commission decides in 2027.
CMP files its petition
Landowners ask the Commission to test the need first
Commission rules need will be decided in the main case
Intervenor testimony filed
Technical conference on intervenor testimony, Hallowell
Commission decides, unless the period is extended
Tell the Commission what you want it to weigh.
Your public comment goes straight into the case record.
